India and Burma: Such Good Friends
|Our Correspondent||Feb 27, 2007|
be a pariah in the eyes of most of the world but India
appears determined to enhance its strategic relationship with the country to
avoid conceding ground to China.
New Delhi is planning a spate of development
projects, including a gas pipeline from the Burmese coast to India, and is now proposing to develop of a Burmese
seaport on the Bay of Bengal to give India's landlocked northeast region
access to commercial sea routes.
In the meantime, the generals who rule Burma under their State Peace and Development
Council junta, have found a lucrative game: playing India
off against China
and winning projects from both.
"The fact that both of the two regional powers, India
and China, want exactly the same thing from Burma puts them in a position very
vulnerable to be exploited by Burma's streetwise generals,” said Tayza Thuria,
a Burmese activist exiled in the United Kingdom. “China,
without having its own seaports for access to the Indian Ocean, would dearly
love to get Indian Ocean access via Burma's rivers and seaports. India also wants the right to use the same
rivers and seaports in Burma
for similar reasons, to provide sea-access to its landlocked states."
At the same time, China's
plans to dam the Salween River, Southeast Asia's second largest, are coming
under fire from environmental groups in the region, who say that Beijing is again showing
little concern for downstream countries that fear its adverse effects. Chinese construction crews began the first
efforts to dam the river this week.
Eventually 13 dams are envisioned for the river, which is one of Burma's
most important water resources. The series of dams are expected to raise
government hackles in Rangoon.
Analysts also expect China to get into the pipeline business with Burma in a big
way. A pipeline through the country and
into Yunnan could save nearly two thousand miles
of sea travel to China’s
South China Sea ports from oil sources in the Middle East.
The junta, meanwhile has approved New
Delhi's proposal to work on the US$212.4 million Kaladan project,
which includes development of the Sittway port in Burma
as well as waterways and road transport to connect the harbor with the
northeastern state of Mizoram, adjacent to Burma’s Chin province.
northeastern region is surrounded by five foreign nations ‑ Nepal, Bhutan,
Tibet, Burma and Bangladesh. Comprised of eight
states with a cumulative population of around 50 million, it is connected to
through what has been described as a chicken's neck. Only 2 percent of the
region's territory is attached to the mainland.
wants to connect the northeast with commercial sea routes,” Indian Commerce
Minister Jairam Ramesh told reporters during a recent visit to the region. “Moreover,
with the development of the Sittway port and the Kaladan River
as navigable, the region is expected to have another viable access to ASEAN
(Association of South East Asian Nations) countries."
Proposed by India
's foreign ministry in 2003, the project includes development of the Kaladan as
a waterway to connect Kaletwa in Burma, then a road to Aizawl, the capital
of poverty-stricken Mizoram. Completion would connect the area directly to
Sittway, the capital of the western Burmese province of Rakhine,
also known as Arakan, which is less than 400 km away from Aizawl.
The project has already been given the go signal by the Indian
Planning Commission and is awaiting formal cabinet approval, Ramesh said,
adding that completion would also allow the movement of cargo ships from
Sittway to other Indian ports.
The Kaladan, the biggest waterway in the region, flows from
Mizoram to Sittway through Chin province. There is also a road connecting Sittway
to China’s Yunnan
province through Mandalay, Burma’s second largest city.
has decided to spend US$103 million initially on developing the seaport. Although
the Burmese junta consented to the proposal, it has refused to invest in the
project, providing only free land use.
To facilitate the investment, the Burmese junta reopened the
Sittway seaport jetty on February 18. The 240-foot jetty, constructed by the
British in 1844, was damaged during a cyclone in 2004.
The project is anticipated to be completed within four years
and will include road construction from Kaletwa in Chin province to the Mizoram
border. The road is designed to connect to India's National Highway 54 inside
Mizoram and will be built by the government-owned Rail India Technical Economic
Another major project is a US$1 billion natural gas pipeline
is eagerly touting. External Affairs Minister, Pranab Mukherjee visited Burma
in January seeking approval, but the junta has said it will delay approval of
the project until it is certain its gas reserves will support it. A decision is
expected in May.
"We are trying to build a pipeline through which we can
get gas directly from the gas fields to our refineries,” Mukherjee said. “Burma
has responded by saying that they are exploring the gas fields and the actual
quantity available will be known only after exploration is complete."
Regardless, both projects raise the ire of activists who fear
a repeat of the forced labor allegations that plagued the Yadana pipeline
project, a joint venture in southern Burma
between Total of France and Unocal of the US. That project ended up in a California court
when Burmese exiles successfully got a suit over human rights issues heard
against UNOCAL before it was finally settled.
Reports have already surfaced in the Burmese exile press of
the involvement of Burmese military units in planning meetings with officials
and engineers in Mizoram for the development of the waterway.
"I would like to ask whether the present situation is
really suitable for investing money and efforts in the country?" said
exile journalist Ko Nyo, who works for US-funded Radio Free Asia’s Burmese
service . He argues that “initiating any kind of project in today's Burma,
implies forced labor and also forced displacement of indigenous people from