Tragedy in Bangladesh
Wake-up call for Bangladesh’s building industry which may never be answered
The eight-storey building that collapsed on April 24 in Bangladesh, killing at least 930, housed five garment factories that employed at least 3,000 workers and placed weight on the floors almost six times greater than the building was intended to bear, according to a still unpublished early damage assessment by the Asian Disaster Preparedness Center.
The study, conducted on the day of the collapse, revealed how a building intended for retail merchants was being used for industrial purposes. Support columns were erected haphazardly. Four huge electrical generators were on the third and fourth floors, possibly contributing to the vibrations that brought the building down. Building materials and methods were below par.
Authorities forced 18 factories to shut down to comply with safety standards although six somehow got up and running again. The Office of the US Trade Representative, Department of State, and Department of Labor, meanwhile, convened a conference call with 70 retailers and manufacturers that do business in Bangladesh to discuss coordinating efforts to improve working conditions. None of the companies said they planned to scale production.
"This is a wake-up call for us because a lot of construction is going on in Dhaka and other cities, so we are definitely trying to find out the solution," said Abdus Salam, a senior research engineer in the government’s Housing and Building Research Institute.
Experts say the building was but one example of a broken system for authorizing, carrying out and monitoring construction. Tens of thousands more buildings – and millions of people inside them – could face the same fate, said Anisur Rahman, an urban planner with ADPC’s office in Bangladesh.
The Bangladesh University of Engineering and Technology is supposed to conduct risk assessments to find the most vulnerable buildings in the capital. Halfway completed is a visual seismic assessment by the government’s Comprehensive Disaster Management Program of some 400,000 buildings, also in the capital area.
Altogether, there are some 1.26 million residential and commercial structures there, according to the Capital Development Authority. There are already some 5,000 cases against owners occupying unsafe buildings in Dhaka, but without court orders city officials have not been able to evict them, said Nurul Huda, the chairman of the Capital Development Authority cannot intervene in municipal planning. Since 2010, processing time has improved somewhat due to three mobile courts handling the backlog, he added.
"It’s a management mess," acknowledged K.Z. Hossain Taufique, an urban planner and director of town planning for the government’s Capital Development Authority, explaining how since the 1980s, as more businesses and people located in cities, responsibility for town planning has been divided between the Housing Ministry and the Ministry of Local Government, creating a patchwork of authorization – and leaving deadly gaps.
Unenforced building codes
The National Building Code from 1993 and building construction guidelines (2008) are rarely – at best weakly – enforced, say government experts. The UN’s highest official for disaster risk reduction, Margareta Wahlstrom, called in 2012 for an update of the building code, a process that had already been underway for a year.to protect the seismically active country from widespread devastation.
But Mohammed Abu Sadeque, director of the governmental Housing and Building Research Institute, which is spearheading the building code’s revision, said with the recent industrial disaster, the problem was not the code, which is "good enough" and "fairly safe and sound", but rather its lack of enforcement.
Corruption and lack of integrity at all levels – from dishonest architects and engineers to profiteering owners and government officials – means cutting corners, said Bashirul Haq, an architect in Dhaka who recently served on a government committee revising the building code.
"Dhaka has limited space. Developers are in this market for money and want to squeeze as much as they can into any space. Yes, we have a law, but who is implementing it?" he asked.
Police have arrested the building’s owner, Mohammed Sohel Rana, as well as the engineer who approved the building’s design.
The current process of signing off construction as safe is haphazard and ill-informed. Although companies should submit detailed plans to their local planning officials, which are then approved by an architect and engineer, mostly only rough sketches and outlines are required now, said Haq.
Local government may not have engineers or architects qualified to give approval, he added.
Poor land use
The building collapse highlights the dangers of unplanned development, said ADPC’s Rahman. According to the 20-year Dhaka Metropolitan Development Plan, effective until 2015, extra attention was to be paid to construction in Savar due to three fault lines that pass through the municipality, making it the "most severe" earthquake zone nationwide.
"That plan has essentially been ignored, something that everyone shares blame [for], starting with the ‘Rajuk’ [Capital Development Authority]," said Rahman.
But due to the 2009 Municipality Act, the Capital Development Authority cannot intervene in municipal planning, Huda told IRIN. "If I were to come over [to Savar’s municipal government] asking questions about land use, they would ask me, ‘Who are you to come here?’"
He said his office has requested the Ministry of Housing and Public Works to "clarify the controversy" surrounding conflicting laws in an effort to regain control of the capital’s planning.
Also needed is a re-evaluation of ways to disperse industrial development to prevent over-construction in any one area, said Rahman. "There are vacant industrial zones to re-locate new factories," he said, mentioning the southwestern city of Khulna (formerly a jute industrial zone) as one way to spread the risk of buildings collapsing in an earthquake.
"Finding a regulatory body to prevent a similar tragedy – that is our goal," said Salam with the Housing and Building Research Institute. He said proposals are circulating on boosting local officials’ expertise on construction standards and safety monitoring, as well as creating high-level district committees that will bring together architects, engineers, health officials and representatives from local government and the Ministry of Housing and Public Works.
Meanwhile, the Urban Development Directorate, part of the Housing Ministry, is seeking government approval to draft a national urbanization plan up to 2021 which would centralize planning power in the Housing Ministry once again.
The country’s Garment Manufacturers’ and Exporters’ Association has asked garment factories in the capital to submit structural drawings, while the labor and employment minister is heading another committee to investigate factories outside the capital.
As of 2011, there were some 5,100 garment factories nationwide employing 3.6 million people, according to the trade organization.
Rahman from ADPC remains skeptical about pledges to reform the building industry. He heard similar promises following a 2005 commercial building collapse in Palash Bari (near the Savar disaster) that killed near 70 and left dozens more missing; a 2010 chemical explosion in a residential area of the capital caused by improperly stored chemicals, which killed 120; and most recently, a fire in a garment factory in November 2012 that killed at least 100.
But Dhaka’s development authority chairman, Huda, said efforts to change have been under way. Since 2010, his request for more engineers and architects has gone through six departments in three ministries for approval. "We hope to be able to recruit more experts soon."
(IRIN is a service of the United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs. This report does not necessarily reflect the views of the United Nations.)