Polls Loom in Singapore
Written by Our Correspondent   
Monday, 04 April 2011
Image
Hsien Loong says things will be just fine
But don't expect much to change

A little under a month remains before Singapore heads to the polls in early May. As always in the strait-laced city state, the run-up to the polls will be a staid affair although for the first time in 23 years the small and fragmented opposition has been able to field candidates in all 84 constituencies.

There will be no US-style presidential debates. Nor will there any of the carnival atmospherics that typify the polls in Australia. The Speaker's Corner, Singapore's version of London's Hyde Park, and the only place in the city where opponents are allowed to speak their minds, was put off limits in mid-March by the government.

Even campaigning in all likelihood will be slated for something like 10 days. Political opponents of the People's Action Party, which has dominated Parliament since 1965 and now holds 82 of the 84 seats, complain there is barely time to deal with the issues facing the island republic.

Those issues are profound, including the impact of hundreds of thousands of foreigners on the nation's economy, the high cost of living, with headline inflation expected by the Monetary Authority of Singapore at 4-5 percent for 2011, the widening income gap between the growing middle class and lower income groups, and the astronomical salaries, by far the highest in the world, paid to Singapore's politicians.

Against that, the economy has been registering torrid growth, with GDP up 14.5 percent in 2010 after falling during the 2007-2008 global financial crisis. GDP growth is expected to moderate to a more sustainable pace in 2011, according to the MAS. Nonetheless, there is a sense on the island that Singapore is hot right now and will stay that way.

Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong has instituted a ‘cooling off' day immediately after the end of all campaigning, ostensibly to allow for a dispassionate reflection of all issues gripping the country, Lee argued in a recent press interview. No election campaigning or advertising will be allowed during the period -- except for news from government-licensed organizations and sanctioned political party broadcasts. The Singapore press is notoriously pro-government.

The new stratagem is to perhaps pre-empt what happened in 1984 when an outraged electorate, bristling at talk of a proposed deferment of the mandatory retirement age from 55 to 60 and along with it the withdrawal of the mandatory nest-egg savings deposited in the Central Provident Fund (CPF) - voted with its feet and began turning in opposition members of parliament.

That episode reduced the PAP's popular vote, causing it to resort in 1988 to the Group Representation Council (GRC) system of electoral voting. Though the PAP then argued the  plan was meant to ensure minority race representation in parliament in an island overtly dominated by Chinese, detractors have not let loose, calling the GRCs "institutionalized gerrymandering." There are 14 Group Representation Constituencies, each with five or six seats, and nine Single Member Constituencies. At least one of the MPs in a GRC must be a member of the Malay, Indian or another minority community. The small and fragmented opposition parties argue that the GRC scheme shackles them because it is more difficult for them to find enough candidates to contest the group constituencies.

The prevailing wisdom is that the PAP is almost guaranteed to remain in power, particularly considering the way the constituencies have been gerrymandered. Only two constituencies went to the opposition in the 2006 election, the first under Lee Hsien Loong, despite the fact that the PAP won just 66.6 percent of the popular vote. Since independence from Malaysia, rarely have Singapore's fragmented and sometimes pathetic opposition groups been able to garner the votes they need and offer an effective and credible political alternative to the PAP.

The element of fear has long stalked Singapore's electorate. Its opposition, members have routinely been arrested, sued, convicted,bankrupted and jailed. In 1981, Joshua B. Jeyaretnam became the first opposition politician since independence to win a seat in Parliament. JBJ, as he was widely known, was re-elected in 1984 but lost his seat after being convicted of falsely accounting his party's funds, a conviction that drew universal condemnation as being rigged.

Jeyaratnam appealed to the Privy Council, the highest court in the British Commonwealth, which overturned the conviction and urged authorities to reinstate him to parliament, calling the conviction a "grave injustice to him and his party chairman Wong Hong Toy." The government refused and subsequently left the jurisdiction of the Privy Council Jeyaretnam was repeatedly hounded from politics only to return time after time until his death in 2008.

That fear is said to be changing. Senior PAP official and Finance Minister Tharman Shanmugaratnam recently said "a strong [political] opposition to be ‘good' for the PAP and Singapore," a statement that 20 years ago would have been political heresy.

Nonetheless, it is questionable how much opposition the PAP thinks would be good for Singapore. Chia Ti Lik, who  recently formed the new opposition party Socialist Front, was found guilty last month on charges of professional misconduct by the Law Society, a tame government front, for alleging that cases filed against opposition figures were politically motivated. That allegedly cast "doubt on the integrity of the judiciary and judicial processes." Chia was also ordered to pay a S3,000 fine.

In January, Chee Soon Juan, the leader of the opposition Singapore Democratic Party, lost his appeal against four convictions for speaking without a permit during the run-up to 2006 elections. High Court Judge Steven Chong imposed a $20,000 fine or 20-week imprisonment in default. The four convictions are part of eight charges filed against Chee for offences committed during the run-up to the elections in 2006. Chee managed to pay the fine through an online donation appeal. Chee and his sister have repeatedly been jailed on a variety of pretexts.

A list of the actions the government has taken to quell dissent from 1994 to 2011, titled 1994-2011: A Chronology of Authoritarian Rule in Singapore, written by Martyn See Tong Ming and published in The Temasek Review, one of Singapore's few independent websites, gives some idea of just how detailed the actions are that the government has taken against the opposition.

However, a growing number of young and well-educated individuals appear prepared to throw in their lot with the opposition. The upcoming election will be the first since 1988 when the PAP will not be returned to power on Nomination Day. In the intervening years, the opposition has been unable to field enough candidates to ensure a theoretical if utterly impossible majority.

That means all major constituencies including the one held by its modern-day founding father and first Prime Minister Lee Kuan Yew will be contested.

Many candidates from both camps come with strong academic credentials, the most notable being Kenneth Jeyaretnam, JBJ's heir and now de facto leader of the Reform Party, which his father founded shortly before he died. In a recent press interview the younger Jeyaretnam told the nation his party was prepared to be that alternative government in the place of the PAP.

It would be folly to suggest that Singapore may have been stung by the jasmine revolution sweeping the Middle East. The conditions that gripped the region, a desire for a vibrant and democratic political culture, are nonexistent in Singapore, an oasis of economic prosperity, a servile press and tightened internet policing.

The hope now is for all that to change, or at least to loosen up a little. The first Saturday of May could be a different kind of Saturday. But it would not be wise for the opposition to count on any big gains.
Comments (10)Add Comment
feedSubscribe to this comment's feed
0
Where is LKY?
written by korrup keling, April 04, 2011
Where is LKY? He is off somewhere talking to other leaders who have given face to him by just listening to him. Nothing concrete will come out of his meetings with them. It is just plain diplomacy to show face to a demented and delusional despot. If he stays in Singapore he will be more depressed. He fears the end as it nears. He will be having nightmares as his wife did before him. How not to? Look the the number of lifes he has destroyed just to stay in power and wealth. He is desperately holding on to power even as his sun sets. He knows he is being cursed to his end. This he cannot stand but what can he do? Perhaps he is trying to bring all his money with him. He will be the first in the world todo so. He will certainly try to do so.
0
Commoners' welfare & standard of living
written by M Marlot, April 04, 2011
"Singapore, an oasis of economic prosperity"
Yes indeed AS thank you.
The Middle East burns today because of massive unemployment.
Hungry people don't care anymore for the koran burning in the States.

Politics in this tiny resourceless island Singapore has been for the ORDINARY AVERAGE citizens who live much much better than their "peers" anyone else in the world. Where here even the minorities Malays and Indians choose to stay with the PAP government rather than migrate in millions like those minorities from Malaysia over the yewars. Even the pro-Muslim Malay policies in Malaysia fail to lure the Singaporean Malays en masse over.

Let the facts speak.

How very interesting . . .
0
the power of the internet
written by Michael Lim, April 05, 2011
Do not underestimate the power of the Internet for this coming Ge2011
The Barisan/UMNO of Malaysia did so in March 2008 and they lost penang, Selangor and Perak.
So also shall the Internet help The Opp parties in S'pore to to win a minimum of 15-20 seats including at leats 2 GRCs.....I said it first here.
0
too many sporeans swallow
written by donald t, April 05, 2011
i recall spore's aging celebrity Zoe Tay's Imedeen advert: "my secret to beautiful skin? i swallow."

sadly for spore, LKY and son can also proclaim: "our secret to dominance? sporeans swallow!"
...line, hook and sinker...

let's see if there are still many sporeans who continue to swallow at the coming polls.
the outcome will say alot about sporeans, whether we can become a nation...

and to be a nation, majority of sporeans must share the same values, i.e stop condoning a govt that is self serving, shamelessly greedy, non accountable, zero on integrity, clueless about leading by example.

Seeing is Believing, Lowly rated comment [Show]
..., Lowly rated comment [Show]
Go Go PAP, Lowly rated comment [Show]
0
sycophants galore
written by toyol, April 06, 2011
There is a whole army of sycophants, agents provocateurs, and eavesdroppers in Singapore. Everything you do and say gets fed to the top. Just as many are paid to write to papers and newspapers to praise the government of LKY(not LSL). All the new chaps coming in are administrators, not politicians - which is what is req'd in singapore. The ideology for newcomers is already decided fo them. In fact ALL the ministers have their ideology determined for them, ie run the country as an outpost for the West. Don't think of democracy - just support the West ineverything they do. That's is why after 45 years, Singapore is still a city - not a country.
Please do some research, Lowly rated comment [Show]
0
Poor Singaporeans
written by nawawi, April 21, 2011
Singapore is a small island city state. There is no "economic of scale" for it to be managed by true and true democratic principle. What LKY has moulded Singapore into at present is still the best.

Singaporeans have been taught to put a cross next to the PAP symbol since pre-school. They have been taught to queue properly, behave themselve and not chewing the gum for voting at the polling stations. The Chinese have been asked to vote for the Malays and the Malays to vote for the Chinese and the rest to vote for the Chinese too. Then they can buy the apartment in the flats and own them for 99 years. They will also be allowed to buy the licence to buy a car. Then they will have to work side by side with the expatriates with some of them having PRs.

Singaporeans have to feel safe, the safest in the world because every Singaporean son is a soldier. Singapore now has a million soldiers compared to its northern neighbour having just 300K.

See, Singapore is rich and many are super rich. Although the majority of the Malays in Singapore are poor, there are quite a few who made it rich. Same with the Indians. The Chinese are still the richest though.Even some beggars in Singapore can earn $15K per month.They are open minded, live in harmony and peaceful with tolerance.

Hey, they have meritrocracy whatever it means!

There are flaws but, there are many flaws everywhere in this world. It is not a perfect world by the way.

Those Singaporeans who have greivances against the Singapore way of doing things must learn to accept it like the rest of the population.

Of course, although there are many good things in Singapore, many other countries are still better.


Write comment

busy