| An Indonesian Campaign to Save a Housewife |
Tag it:
| Written by Ben Bland | |
| Friday, 18 December 2009 | |
 Photo: Prita Mulysari, Jakarta Globe There was nothing remarkable about Prita Mulyasari's decision to email a few friends to complain about the treatment she had received at a private hospital on the outskirts of Jakarta last year. On paying a lot of money for any particular service, whether it's health care, car repairs or plumbing, most people would grumble to their friends if they felt they'd got a raw deal. But when her friends forwarded the note, they unwittingly put into motion a chain of events that catapulted the 32-year-old bank worker from suburban anonymity into headline news and sparked a national outcry against the uneven nature of the justice system in Indonesia. Prita's email criticized Omni International Hospital and two of its doctors, who she claimed had misdiagnosed her as suffering from dengue fever when, in fact, she had mumps. She initially sent the note to just 20 friends, relatives and colleagues but once they began passing it on, it ended up being posted on a mailing list for doctors and was ultimately brought to the attention of the hospital. Their response wasn't what most people would think of as measured: Omni filed a civil defamation suit against the mother of two, while the two doctors launched a separate criminal defamation suit. After being charged with criminal defamation, Prita was locked up at the Tangerang women's penitentiary in May, at which time she was still breastfeeding her second child. News of her predicament had already begun seeping out through messages boards and social networking sites such as Facebook and the decision to jail her crystallized online curiosity into a rapidly-growing internet campaign. The burgeoning public anger at the way she was being treated forced the authorities to release her from jail after three weeks on condition that she not abscond. Prita lost the civil case regardless and was ordered to pay Omni Rp204 million ($21,600) in damages - a decision upheld by a higher court earlier this month. The good citizens of Indonesia - channeling their energies through Facebook and blogs - came to her aid once again, launching a "coins for Prita" campaign to raise the necessary funds to cover the damages and any associated legal costs. The campaign caught the public mood with everyone from politicians to businessmen and garbage scavengers to school children chipping in. By the time the collection drive closed on Monday, Prita's supporters had raked in well over Rp500 million, with many more donations still to arrive in Jakarta from elsewhere in the sprawling archipelago. Amid such overwhelming public support for Prita, the hospital finally realized that its reputation management efforts had rather backfired and, last week, it offered to drop its civil suit against Prita on the condition that her lawyer drops a Rp1 trillion countersuit. However, Prita has refused to settle with Omni unless the two doctors withdraw their support for the criminal prosecution, which is still in progress. Legal experts say that there is no mechanism to abandon a criminal trial once it is underway and the presiding judge told Prita on Tuesday that they would reach a verdict within two weeks. With the prosecutors having called for a six-month prison sentence, Prita's fate still hangs in the balance. Whatever the eventual outcome, the whole saga reveals a great deal - both positive and negative - about a country that, while undoubtedly on the way up, is still very much in transition. Living in a gated community outside Jakarta, Prita makes for a rather unlikely voice of the downtrodden. It seems bizarre that the malnourished and the poverty-stricken would hand over their hard-earned and much-needed cash to help out a middle-class bank employee who got into trouble by complaining about the service at her private hospital. But Prita's case has struck such a chord across Indonesia because it embodies just how corrupt and unfair most people perceive the justice system to be. In almost every country in the world, developing or developed, there is a widespread belief that the scales of justice are tipped massively in favor of the rich - just ask most Americans what they think about the OJ Simpson case or look at some of the recent scandals in Malaysia. But in Indonesia, that sense is particularly acute and for good reason. Although successive governments have made some progress in the fight to root out the graft that permeated all areas of society under Suharto's rule, Indonesia remains one of the most corrupt nations in the world. Indonesia ranked 111th of 180 countries in the latest Corruption Perception Index by Transparency International, a well-respected anti-graft campaign group. And the justice system is widely considered to be the worst of a bad bunch. Part of the problem stems from the proliferation of shady "case brokers" - known as "makelar kasus" or "markus" for short - who can halt arrests, intimidate witnesses and destroy evidence for an appropriate fee. While the kleptomaniac oligarchs and money-grabbing politicians are rarely forced to justify their actions in a court of law, ordinary folk, who do not have the financial ammunition to block police investigations or pay off judges, are given no such quarter. Prita's case is only one of several recent causes celebres that have focused public attention on the problem. There is Minah, the illiterate 55-year-old grandmother from central Java forced to face criminal charges after stealing three cocoa pods; West Jakarta resident Aguswandi Tanjung, who was arrested for "stealing electricity" after daring to charge his mobile phone in the hallway of the apartment block where he lives; and the two men from East Java who were remanded in custody for 70 days after stealing a solitary watermelon. Perhaps the extra cash collected by the coins for Prita campaign could go toward establishing a fund to help poor crooks buy their way out of trouble in the same way that Indonesia's moneyed felons do? That might not do much to restore popular faith in Indonesian justice but it would rebalance the scales a little while the county awaits the reforms that were promised by President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono during the July elections and that helped him win a strong mandate from the people. In the meantime, there is always Facebook, which allows Indonesia's politically-active masses to protest from the comfort of their bedroom rather than sweating it out in one of the real-world demonstrations that take place almost every day at the Hotel Indonesia roundabout in central Jakarta. Although as the Prita case shows only too well, the internet is not a one-way street for those seeking to air dissenting views. It is merely another arena in which battle can be joined. The internet may help save Prita in the end but it was the highly-contagious nature of electronic communications that got her into trouble in the first place. Ben Bland is a freelance journalist based in Jakarta. He blogs at http://www.asiancorrespondent.com/the-asia-file. Comments
(4)
 written by Nikhilesh.. , January 02, 2010
Very interesting, insightful and well written story, as per usual from Asia sentinel.
Votes: +0
http://www.nytimes.com/aponline/2009/12/29/world/AP-AS-Indonesia-Patient-Charged.html report abuse
vote down
vote up
The article does not mention whether the housewife allegation was true or not.
Votes: +1
If the allegation was proven true, how can she be sued for defamation? Unless thats how one of the most corrupted country in south east asia works.. Ha ha ha... NOW will this bloody Indo country sue me for writing that here? well they are bloody welcomed. report abuse
vote down
vote up
written by John Francis Lee , December 18, 2009
' Whatever the eventual outcome, the whole saga reveals a great deal - both positive and negative - about a country that, while undoubtedly on the way up, is still very much in transition. '
Votes: +1
On the way up?! Are you crazy? It is obviously on the way down, ruled by thugs disguised as doctors and gangsters disguised as hospitals. The positive note is that the overthrow of the present regime seems imminent. The good people of Indonesia are fed up and getting organized. Once they're organized... the bigger the come, the harder they fall, one and all. report abuse
vote down
vote up
|
Subscribe to this comment's feed
Show/Hide comments
Show/Hide comment form
India's Thirst for EnergySiddharth Srivastava Coal surge is unabated, raising environmental concerns
Full Story |
| Other Articles |
Indonesia's Mediocre Harvard Grade A comprehensive report finds depressing vestiges of the Suharto are still around
Full Story |
| most read... |
Alice Poon
| Anti-Anti-Speculation ActionTuesday, 24 August 2010 | Alice Poon (潘慧嫻)
It seems that the SAR government finally decided to choose
the lesser of two evils: taking decisive, albeit belated, anti-speculation
measures in the hope of stabilizing prices, rather than... Full Story |
| Previous posts: |
John Elliott: Riding the Elephant
| From vultures in Delhi, to coups in Pakistan, a journalist's un-edited take on current events |
|
Donate to Asia Sentinel
China is often used as a benchmark for being "on the way up" or upwardly mobile. If this is the case, J.F. Lee speaks for the whole of the developing world as a whole, scary!